Print Email RSS RSS  Share del.icio.us Facebook Twitter
What Will iPad’s Role Be in Home Automation?
Is Apple's new hit a match made in heaven or a really bad combo?
image
March 25, 2010 | by Lisa Montgomery

Just a couple of more weeks until the coveted Apple iPad will be in the hands of the tech-hungry. Right out of the box, there’s a lot you’ll be able to do with the device.

So what about using it to control electronic devices in your home?

You can already do this by downloading one of the scads of control applications available onto an iPhone or iPod touch and most should work for the iPad when it arrives (automation giant Crestron has already touted its iPad app version), so is there hope for a multifunctional, portable 9.7-inch screen as a home control device? Along with Crestron, we know Apple-based automation provider Savant thinks the answer is a big “yes.”

We decided to ask a few seasoned custom electronics professionals (CE pros) for their take on the technology and how they think it’ll impact the way we manage our household electronics.

The Good

Big Screen
The almost 10-inch screen provides plenty of real estate for displaying information about and controls for electronic devices. “The more space you have on a screen, the less you’ll have to scroll or flip to get to what you want,” says Derek Cowburn of DistinctAV, McCordsville, Ind. “This will make it a great interface for managing large collections of media, and for browsing information. For example, with the iPad you’d be able to browse on-demand listings without having to turn on the TV.”

Cost
Priced starting at $499 for its April 3 intro, the iPad may be a little pricey, but it’s still less expensive than most home control touchpanels of similar size. “It’s poised to open up opportunities for people interested in home control but who can’t afford a large-size touchpanel from a home control manufacturer,” says Joe Calderaro of Audio Video Interiors, Medina, Ohio.

Apple Backing
Almost every manufacturer of home control system already offers an app for the iPhone and iPod touch. You can bet they’ll be doing the same (if they haven’t already) for the iPad. “Once the control manufacturers are on board, the iPad will be a real game changer,” says Ryan Herd of One Sound Choice, Pompton Plains, N.J.


The Bad

Tough to Operate
Apps may help leverage the iPad as a home control device, but at a potential risk to its usability. “People aren’t going to want to have to constantly switch between different apps to control different things,” Cowburn explains. “If all the controls can tie back to a single app, then the iPad becomes a very powerful device.” Currently, Savant is one of the only Apple-based home control systems on the market, and has recently developed an app for the iPad.

Easy to Misplace
Unlike an iPhone that’s usually in your pocket, the iPad will likely be carted around the house by everyone in the family. This may sound super convenient, but just wait until someone leaves it where you can’t find it.

Too Much Stuff
A jack of all trades, a master of none is how some CE pros describe multifunctional products like the iPad. Calderaro compares it to his BlackBerry. “My BlackBerry takes pictures, and I’ll occasionally use it to take a quick snapshot, but if I want good pictures I’ll use my camera.” Similarly, he thinks the iPad will be used occasionally as to operate electronic devices, but for serious control consumer will continue to rely on interfaces designed explicitly for the task.

Tell us: Would you like to use your new iPad to control the lights, thermostats, A/V equipment and other devices in your house?

 



Lisa Montgomery - Contributing Writer
Lisa Montgomery has been writing about home technology for 15 years, with a focus on the impact of electronics on a modern lifestyle.



Article Topics
What's Related
Popular Tags
Social Bookmark   less


Comments (20) Most recent displayed first.
Posted by Eric  on  03/26/10  at  05:37 PM

Sorry, I get sparky. We as pro automators generally mark up our products plus labor to total around 30% of the overall cost. Believe it or not, that is our break between profitable and out of business. The manufacturers price is set by their cost of developing, manufacturing and bringing to market the finished product.The more they sell, the more you will see a affordable price point, plan on seeing Savant continue to find ways to get the product to a wider audience.

Now if you stray from the beaten path, you can build a pretty cool system. Instead of a protege system, you can purchase a OSD1010, giving you the awesome on screen display, on screen widgets, safari on the big screen and much more and reuse your older equipment controlled by Savant to have a great platform for equipment price closer to around 4G. Very cool system. I love the OSD. Depending on how much programming, the price can be kept down!

Posted by Brian  on  03/26/10  at  02:39 PM

No worries Michael - I figured as much.

My main beef is I’m a hobbyist when it comes to the home theater stuff.  I’ve got a pretty great setup considering I’ve done 95% of it myself.  I’m an IT guy and have been for years.  It drives me crazy that Crestron, Savant, etc. charge these crazy prices when it comes to installing and configuring these systems.  And to sell the main brains of the unit for a low low entry point of $5k is just insane.  The Prodigy is much closer to my price range, and I can tinker with it all I want instead of calling out a developer/programmer each time I want to make an adjustment.

I know most folks out there don’t stand a chance with regards of installing this stuff, but there are a few folks out there who do.  The price of admission is just a little more than I can bear. 

I know I’m whining about it… I keep hoping that if I #### an moan about it long enough I might start to feel better that I can’t afford it and just go with a Insteon system and suffer the outcome of that.  :D

Posted by Michael  on  03/26/10  at  02:10 PM

Sorry Brian…that was directed at “Eric’s” post

Posted by Michael  on  03/26/10  at  12:25 PM

Brian -

I don’t believe I compared the Prodigy Processor to the Savant anywhere in my post.

I think the Savant system is a fantastic bargain in relative terms.

However Prodigy is also a great system for someone looking for control over their AV gear and simple reliable home automation at an extremely affordable price point.  Prodigy also has the ability to add rooms of audio and climate control, lighting, security integration, an Iphone app, as well as the ability to add an Xpanel. 

This should bring automation control capability to many people who thought it was out of their price range.  Or at least a price range they were comfortable with.

This isn’t comparing Prodigy with Savant any more than comparing Honda to Porsche.  Just stating what its capabilities are at its price point thats all.

Posted by Eric  on  03/25/10  at  07:31 PM

Are you kidding? Your really going to compare a prodigy processor with the savant package that has a built in itunes server, supports 8 rooms of audio, just add amp, an ipod touch, a developer environment that tears through the limitations of prodigy like scissors through paper. Really? I have worked with all of the control platforms on the market and the truth is you get what you pay for, there are no shortcuts.


+ View all comments on for this article



Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.