View our Product Guide
Electronic House Newsletter   View sample
 
Popular Stories
View Home of the Year '09.
Recent Comments
Bill (02/09, 05:32 PM)
Kenneth Lawson (02/09, 02:36 PM)
MrWhite (02/09, 11:55 AM)
wildcatherder (02/09, 11:45 AM)
Jon Z (02/09, 11:01 AM)
Recent Slideshow Galleries
Couples Retreat on Blu-ray 10 Coolest Apple Products Best Products of CES 2010 Grading Future Technologies Top 10 Blu-ray Releases for January 19 Fun and Games on L.A. Home’s 7 Consoles, 103” Plasma 3D TVs from CES 2010 On the Scene at CES 2010 A Roundup of 3D Blu-ray Players Coolest TV Innovations from CES 2010 5 Ridiculously Expensive Blu-ray Players 24 Ways to Rack Your Gear 11 Innovative Products at CEA i-stage 12 Wiring Cleanup Jobs Top 50 Blu-ray Releases of 2009 DIYer Displays the Art of Home Theater
Cool Homes Feature
A Stargate Atlantis Theater is Born
A Stargate Atlantis Theater is Born
And how much will it cost for your own escape across the universe?

Themed Home Theaters
View Designing a Death Star Theater
Designing a Death Star Home Theater
Three separate rooms, one starfield, and a life-sized Han Solo are just a few of the things that help two super "Star Wars" fans get their geek on in this theater.

Site Sections
Services
Ask a Pro
Q. Can I Encase My Subwoofer in a Cabinet?
Encasing a subwoofer will compromise the sound. But here are some tips for making the best of a tight situation.
About this Pro
Simon Scotland
Also Filed in Ask a Pro

Submit your question and one of our pros will try to get you an answer!

Question:
required
Please enter your first name and location to be displayed with your question if published.
Your Name/Location:
optional
Your E-mail Address:
required
Subscribe to the free Electronic House newsletter today!
Email Newsletter:
optional

Yes   No

February 18, 2009 | by Simon Scotland

Q. I have a Paradigm PW2200 subwoofer and would like to enclose it into a cabinet. Can I port it and speaker cover the front? - Charles, Ohio

A. Placing the subwoofer in a cabinet will compromise the sound. The sub may sound great sitting out in the open now, but that will likely change if it’s moved into the cabinet.

Here are some tips for your situation:

  • Make sure the subwoofer fits tightly inside the cabinet. You don’t want sound booming inside there. To limit this, you can pack acoustic material or insulation around the sub.
  • If the sub has a reflex port, you’ll need to attach a tight-fitting pipe that leads outside the enclosure. This will probably affect the sound of the sub too.
  • Make sure the cabinet’s front cover is secure. While it might be amusing to have the door fly open from an explosion in a movie, any rattling will drive you insane.

A better solution is to buy a subwoofer that is designed to be installed in millwork or walls. We like the iWS from NHT or any of the in-wall/in-ceiling subs from Triad. Since these subs are designed for this type of use, you won’t suffer from the acoustic changes.

In general, subwoofer placement is always a tricky issue. In an ideal world, room layout should dictate placement. The most basic technique involves placing the subwoofer in the sitting area and then walk around the room to find out where the bass sounds best. Move the subwoofer to that location. If that isn’t possible, try the subwoofer in all available positions and then pick the one which sounds best.

Many people and companies suggest placing a subwoofer in the corner of a room. This will certainly enhance the effect of the bass. However this can lead to too much bass which you then need to control. With bass there is always a “correct” level and a level which you prefer. Some people are just more into bass than others.

Related articles:
Feel the Power of Subwoofers
Buying the Right Subwoofer
The World’s Largest Subwoofer?



About the Author:
Simon Scotland - CEO, Beyond the Invisible Ltd
Simon spent eight years in the feature film production. Upon leaving the industry he formed Beyond the Invisible in London UK which specializes in high end whole house entertainment systems, home theaters and lighting control and currently has a staff on ten. He is a certified CEDIA designer and avid collector of Citroen automobiles.



Article Topics
Popular Tags
Social Bookmark   less


Comments (7) Most recent displayed first.
Posted by CJ  on  02/28/09  at  10:15 AM

Here is another alternative.  First let me say that from a pure a/v point-of-view,what was mentioned by Simon is the best and right way to do things.  However, in the past I have been dictated by owners and/or interior designers that it must go in the cabinet.  The solution for this which works rather well is the following:
First, to measure the footprint of the subwoofer, lets say it’s 15"wide x 15” deep, then to cut a hole an inch bigger on all sides in the bottom shelf (hole will be 17"x17”).  This will allow the subwoofer to sit on the ‘floor’ of the room, so when a Low Frequency Effect (LFE) occurs, the sub won’t rattle the cabinet, and the nick-nacks that are in it.  If this is a new cabinet being built have the cabinet maker place some cleats where the hole cut is made and a finger pull in the cut piece so it can be reinstalled later if needed.  (By the way, when measuring, make sure that you clear the power cord, and the back of the amplifiers cooling fins, also save this panel so you can reinstall it, should you not want a subwoofer there anymore.)  Also once the floor of the cabinet’s bay is cut you could place the subwoofer on a hard piece of foam to raise it.  The main point of this, is to isolate the subwoofers vibrations from the cabinet.
Second, if your cabinet has a toe kick, you will want to cut a couple of slots in the very front of the bottom shelf so the air(sound) can ‘vent’ from the subwoofer into the room.  As an example if your cabinet’s subwoofer bay is 24” wide (inside finish dimensions) then I would cut (2) 1” wide x 10” slots.  If this is done correctly, you should be able to face the cabinet, and while squating down, place your hand palm up just in front of the toe kick, and your fingers would come up into the subwoofers cabinet bay space, just behind the closed door.  This would allow you to keep all the front doors looking the same and not have some panels that are solid wood, and one that has speaker fabric for the subwoofer.
Couple of things to consider.  If your subwoofer’s is a bottom-firing unit, then you will want to place the sub on it’s side (and measure the cut hole for it lying down) so the driver faces the front of the cabinet.  You can also calculate or increase the amount of volume coming into the room by cutting holes in the vertical divider support that divides the subwoofer bay from the adjacent bay, and then cut an additional set of slots as mentioned above, to increase the amount of venting into the room.

Posted by Dr. Bonnie  on  02/20/09  at  01:07 PM

SoundSense has performed several acoustic studies on this problem.  Our original study was on speakers recessed in a wall or ceiling.  We have specifically designed a material called QB speaker and QB subwoofer to prevent some of the standard acoustic problems and anomalies associated with placing a speaker or subwoofer in an enclosure.  One problem with the subwoofer is that the acoustic wave interacts with the structure in which it is placed.  This in turn interacts with and complicates and corrupts the wave from the subwoofer.  QB subwoofer is designed to minimize this problem, as well as a few other problems associated with the subwoofer in an enclosure.  Further questions can be answered by emailing me or calling 877-NoiseOut

Posted by Xander  on  02/20/09  at  12:23 PM

Put down the keyboard. Pick up a dictionary.

Posted by Phillip Wortunnaga  on  02/20/09  at  12:15 PM

“If the sub has a reflex port, you’ll need to attach a tight-fitting pipe that leads outside the enclosure. This will probably affect the sound of the sub too. “

“This will have a drastic change in the sub’s tuning. I would never suggest this. You may damage your driver by extending the port because it will lower the tune, possibly well below the driver’s FS. “


Not if you tight-washed the inside of the bass-blower.  Holding the upper half to the bottom, you could easily torch the operator.  The wind-driven cone could be turned all over and revised with turns and dips.

Posted by Xander  on  02/20/09  at  10:06 AM

“If the sub has a reflex port, you’ll need to attach a tight-fitting pipe that leads outside the enclosure. This will probably affect the sound of the sub too. “

This will have a drastic change in the sub’s tuning. I would never suggest this. You may damage your driver by extending the port because it will lower the tune, possibly well below the driver’s FS.


+ View all comments on for this article



Post a Comment

Name:

Email:


View comment guidelines

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please answer the question below:

Type the first letter of the word "stereo":





Learn more about products and solutions from tech companies.
Electronic House magazine's 2009 Best Homes of the Year special.
Electronic House reviews the coolest products of the year.
Visit the Electronic House Ideas store & get more out of your home!

Stay up-to-date with home electronics. Get your print subscription today.
Weekly email offers tips, info and product news.
Subscribe today!
Get the content that's important to you.
More about RSS.
Electronic House is now available in a digital edition. Learn more.
About us Advertise Magazine Newsletters Digital issues EH Publishing Privacy policy Contact us
 Copyright © 2006 EH Publishing. All rights reserved.
EH Network: CE Pro TecHome Builder ChannelPro ProSoundWeb Church Production Electronic House Expo Worship Facilities Expo