Print Email RSS RSS  Share del.icio.us Facebook Twitter
Is Your DVD Server Legal? Manufacturers­ Say Yes!
Developers of movie-ripping products insist their products are legal. Here's how the manufacturers address the sticky issue of digital rights management (DRM).
image
October 01, 2008 | by Julie Jacobson

Escient - Vision
From CE Pro’s interview with Chris Commons, Escient vice president, product planning and development.

When Vision was first announced last year, you could not copy DVDs to the server from its built-in disk drive. Now you can. What changed?
[Initially] we were telling everyone that there were legal issues surrounding the importing of movies. We’ve resolved those issues so you can import movies on the front-panel DVD drive.

Exactly how did Escient “resolve” those issues?
We’re maintaining all of the encryption that’s on the movie so when we’re moving a movie from a disc to the internal hard drive, it’s copying bit for bit with all of the encryption intact. We’re adding our own second level of even more stringent encryption to protect it [DVD content] when it’s on the Vision storage system.

Axonix - MediaMax
From the Online Axonix FAQ

What about copyright laws? Is there information on how to obey copyright laws?
Click here to read the article “Fair Use? How to Back Up DVD Movies”
Click to read the article “Fair Use Frequently Asked Questions (and Answers)”.
For additional information contact your Axonix Project Manager by clicking here

Fuze Media - Fuze One
From interview with Fuze’s Bob Silver

Initially, Fuze expected users to find and download their own DVD copying software. Now you’ve made it easier for them. Why the change?
We felt there were adequate solutions for getting DVDs onto the system, so we left it alone for DRM purposes.

But people want a brain-dead way of doing it. We decided we could make it easier with our new DVD Importer [application].

The way we’re dealing with the legality is that our product by itself will not rip a DVD if you try to put a content-protected disk in.

The customer needs to go online and buy copy of AnyDVD from SlySoft. It resides in the background of the computer and decrypts any type of encrypted DVD that you put in the computer. Our software sees the DVD as an unencrypted DVD and imports it without any type of encryption.

We’re not unencrypting DVDs; AnyDVD is. We’re clean.



Julie Jacobson - Editor, Electronic House; Editor-at-large, CE Pro
Julie Jacobson is editor of Electronic House and editor-at-large for CE Pro magazine, the trade magazine for home technology. She co-founded parent company EH Publishing in 1994.



Article Topics
What's Related
Popular Tags
Social Bookmark   less


Comments (2) Most recent displayed first.
Posted by Julie Jacobson  on  10/01/08  at  03:34 PM

Wim ... We don’t know that yet. Mfrs are claiming Yes, but the courts have yet to decide.

It looks like RealDVD is the first to be sued by the studios under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. That will be an important one to watch.

You can read more about that here and here.

Posted by Wim  on  10/01/08  at  03:29 PM

So basically any product that pulls a bit for bit copy of a dvd as an ISO without tampering with encryption is in the clear?



Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.