Print Email RSS RSS  Share del.icio.us Facebook Twitter
Great Movie Scenes to Test Your Home Theater
These movies scenes are a great gauge of just how good - or bad - your TV's picture is.
Test Your Home Theater
Slideshow
image
View Slideshow

March 04, 2008 | by Marshal Rosenthal

How can you tell that your TV or front projector is operating on all cylinders? That simple question can be quite deceptive because we all see things a bit differently. And since most displays come with a default setting that’s rarely on the money, getting the best image is always going to come from tweaking the various controls until it looks good to you. Still, there are a few things to look for that can give you a clue as to how well your display is working. So with a nod to Rod Serling, we submit for your approval the following favorite scenes as examples of what can show off - or show up - that image you are watching.

Bullitt (HD DVD/Blu-ray - Warner Home Video)
Passing over just how cool Steve McQueen is here, right from the opening credits to pretty much any scene (especially those at the airport), the one thing that stands out in this film is the grain of the image. It should look crisp, not blotchy. The contrast level should be moderate enough to keep dark and light areas from going to extremes. For why high-def makes a DVD sorry, check out the lab scene with Jaqueline Bisset and that rotating “hypnotic eye” - which will also let you see how cleanly black and white is being resolved.

Blade Runner/The Final Cut (HD DVD/Blu-ray Warner Home Video)
In the “Eye On The City” chapter you get an incredible overlay of decrepit architecture, technology, and people. All that urban debris should be distinct to the eye, while not blending into one another. The colors may be muted but still separate without any bleeding.

Exotic Saltwater Aquarium (Blu-ray/DVD International)
This disc provides a fast report on how the display reproduces a broad range of colors, both subtle and bold. Start with the Classic Tank and as waves of relaxation flow over you, look for how well the fish are delineated in the water. There should be fine detail without any motion blur or “smearing” as the fish pass by.

The Matrix Revolutions (HD DVD/Warner Home Video)
Focus on the final non-stop battle between Neo and Agent Smith. Is the display giving you separation between the overabundance of black wrapping the characters and the CG rain falling on top of them? Having a well moderated contrast is a must here or else objects will start to merge together, and if the display has problems with fast moving objects, it will certainly show up here.

Paprika (Blu-ray/Sony Entertainment)
It’s The Easter Beagle, Charlie Brown (DVD/Warner Home Video)
Academy Awards Animation Collection (DVD/Warner Home Video)
Pure animated films provide a way to check color balance, contrast and black and white levels. “Paprika” works well because it has a riot of color both strong and subtle. Another choice is one of the older Charlie Brown DVDs, because the simplified color palette makes it easier to know if the images are too soft or lacking contrast. And the remastered Superman cartoon from Max Fleischer’s Studios (found as part of Warner’s Animated Academy Awards Collection) can provide an astounding image, thanks to the most expensive budget for a cartoon at the time and the use of motion-capture. The display should have no problem capturing the solid, yet somewhat soft and muted colors, as well as the rich detail. A great example is the aerial view of a devastated Metropolis witnessed from the Man of Steel’s perspective as he whisks the Mad Scientist off to jail.

Across the Universe (Blu-ray/Sony Entertainment)
There are fair amounts of detail but the one thing this film tosses out in abundance are skin tones. So check out how the characters look: are their faces pancake-flat or is there the shading and subtle details that render faces real to the eye? Of course that all goes out the window when “Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds” starts up: offering a rare chance to evaluate a psychedelic glow of colors without an out-of-body experience.

Good Night, and Good Luck (HD DVD/Blu-ray Warner Home Video)
The Man From U.N.C.L.E. - The Complete Collection (DVD/Time Life Productions)
A black and white film easily betrays whether colors don’t stay “put” and are infiltrating an image. The advantage of viewing “Good Night” in HD is that you can quickly see whether the contrast levels are where they should be. This is even more true of older titles where film grain can also become more agitated as a result, such as the burst of smoke that Thrush uses to render the agent in the tailor shop entrance to U.N.C.L.E.’s HQ.

Die Hard (Blu-ray/Twentieth Century Fox Home Entertainment)
The first of the series suffers greatly in high-definition. But it provides a template for comparison to other films as to how your display handles serious imaging issues. Focus on the scene where Bruce Willis jumps from the roof as the helicopter explodes overhead with a number of image artifact problems surrounding the scene. Watch how light reflects off objects, the explosion and even the main character’s torso to see whether the display can handle “grittier” color with some extreme contrast.

You Tell Us
What’s your favorite calibration scene? How about audio? Comment below!



Article Topics
What's Related
Popular Tags
Social Bookmark   less


Comments (20) Most recent displayed first.
Posted by Alan Brown  on  03/04/08  at  02:31 PM

“Creative spin,” that explains why I got dizzy just reading it.  I was linked to this article from AVScience forum’s home page.  Unfortunately, two decades of imaging science advocacy by the home entertainment media has gradually become more and more compromised and watered down.  Some of your readers may find your approach interesting, but I doubt seriously the average consumer will understand better how to correct what such a “test” might reveal or properly adjust their TV picture controls.  I realize you have space constraints but reading your article had me literally squirming in my seat. 

Your publication is certainly capable of excellent work.  This one just got my attention, and seriously disappointed me.  My expectation is that it will only serve to further confuse and burden the typical video consumer.

Best regards,
Alan Brown, President
CinemaQuest, Inc.,

“Advancing the art and science of electronic imaging”

Posted by Chuck McKenney  on  03/04/08  at  01:39 PM

Thanks Video Savant for your input. But we have done numerous articles on calibration.

- Get the Best Picture from Your New TV
- How Can I Tell If My TV Needs to Be Calibrated?
- Coming Soon: Self-Calibrating Home Theaters

We are simply putting a creative spin on a topic which has already been covered.

Posted by Video Savant  on  03/04/08  at  01:30 PM

This article does a disservice to anyone who genuinely wants to know whether his or her HDTV or home theater display is providing accurate images. I’m certain that anyone relying on this article for picture quality guidance will end up worse off than where they started and be mostly clueless as to why, how and when it happened.

I’m an imaging science professional, and I recognize that most people don’t really care about picture quality—at least not enough to take the time to learn what quality imaging is actually about and how to go about accomplishing it. For most consumers buying a new TV, whatever comes out of the box is miles better than what they had before, and thanks to HDTV and high quality programming sources now available to the average consumer, this is a truly worthwhile development.

But if you really care about image quality and you want to do some basic picture quality “due diligence,” then you should grab either the Digital Video Essentials or Monster/ISF HDTV Calibration Wizard test discs.

Using these test discs to adjust the basic user controls should yield actual, objective picture quality improvements, as well as providing some basic explanations about both the how and why of basic display setup. These discs cost less than $50, and in many cases can be found at public or lending libraries.

Going the test disc route will get the determined viewer about 75% of the way to accurate imaging. For those who desire something a lot closer to the ideal, they should contact a trained video calibrator who can explain the basics of professional calibration and whether it would be of benefit, based on room environment, viewing preferences and budget:

http://www.isfforum.com/sobi2/ISF-Forum-Calibrators/Americas/United-States.html

Posted by Jon  on  03/04/08  at  11:44 AM

Old standard for audio is the “Blue Lady” scene from 5th element.  Superbit is a better format for audio testing if you can find it.  Her vocal range is across the board on the high end, and the fighting interspersed through the scene is great for your mids and lows. 

Also good for testing surround sound is the big “lots of guns” fight scene in the first Matrix. 

Finally, close to the beginning of XXX is a short scene where a dart or something is shot from the back right to the center.  It’s a really good test of your surround separation, as you can actually hear it run from over your shoulder to directly in front of you.  Can’t recommend the movie for much else though..

Oh ya…found you via stumbleupon!

Posted by Scott Elder  on  03/04/08  at  10:54 AM

Opening scene of the first Pirates Of The Carribean film on Blu Ray is the best test of flicker for any LCD projector or projection TV.  The haze in that scene will reveal vertical bars like nothing else.


+ View all comments on for this article



Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.