vizioxvt Vizio Shows Off New 55-inch LCD, HD Sound Bar
The 1080p XVT packs a 50,000:1 contrast ratio, 120Hz refresh rate and 5 HDMI inputs, for $1,999.

flatwire FlatWire: Scared Off by the Spackling
FlatWire can help remove your A/V cable clutter, provided you're capable of spackling, sanding and painting.

View our Ultimate Holiday Gift Guide for 2008
Electronic House Newsletter   View sample
 
Popular Stories
View 40 winning homes. Best Home Theater, Family Room and more.
Recent Comments
Wim (11/22, 08:39 AM)
Lass (11/22, 06:39 AM)
John (11/22, 05:10 AM)
BUZKIL99 (11/22, 02:48 AM)
Camaperjoe (11/22, 01:02 AM)
Recent Slideshow Galleries
FlatWire: Scared Off by the Spackling Uber Home Blends Tech, Style and Green 8 Video Games That Will Keep You In Shape Will New Xbox Experience Kill Apple TV? Off to the Races with Christina Milian definitive procinema1000 Party House Loaded with High-Tech Favors Speed Up Your A/V Network with Dual-Band Routers 4 Home Auto­mation Systems­ for $200 or Less Garage Mahal Active vs Passive Speakers: Which to Use? Vincent Bova DIY Theater gators theater The Ultimate Holiday Gift Guide for 2008 Silver Surfer Theater 6 Killer Plasma TVs
Info and Answers Feature
FlatWire: Scared Off by the Spackling
FlatWire: Scared Off by the Spackling
FlatWire can help remove your A/V cable clutter, provided you’re capable of spackling, sanding and painting.

Themed Home Theaters
View Designing a Death Star Theater
Designing a Death Star Home Theater
Three separate rooms, one starfield, and a life-sized Han Solo are just a few of the things that help two super "Star Wars" fans get their geek on in this theater.

Site Sections
Services
IPTV
Are Media Extenders Finally Catching On?
Do you really want to watch TV on your PC…or your PC on your TV?
image

NBC’s Internet based coverage carries twice as much coverage of some categories and most of the top events both live and on-demand.

Slideshow
image
View Slideshow

Also Filed in IPTV

August 20, 2008 | by Richard M. Sherwin

Could the Olympics with NBC’s integrated coverage from many platforms including regular TV, On-line TV, On-line on-demand TV and mobile phone TV be the catalyst in making the 10 year history of trying to converge TV and PC content a success?

So far, it seems that millions of consumers are participating in all genres of Olympic TV watching. NBC’s web based video is available live and pre-recorded. But more importantly, consumers seem to be using the online on-demand version of Michael Phelps & Co. The result from this coverage is that record breaking numbers of people are using web based video on their PC and on their TV instead of viewing traditional TV only content.

Viewers are seeing clearly marked “live” events unlike TV coverage which has a 12 hour delay. They are getting live web coverage on their Media Center TVs or Media center Extenders or just their PC. This is the first time viewers are able to view and enjoy content for an extended period of time for more than one event like the Super Bowl or Academy Awards. It’s compelling and sort of must see TV-PC.

NBC is averaging nearly 60 hours of integrated TV coverage on regular television through six channels NBC, CNBC, MSNBC, Telemundo, Oxygen and USA Network. But, despite the ultra annoying 15 second commercials that are not fast-forward-able, its Internet based coverage on NBCOlympics.com carries twice as much coverage of some categories and most of the top events both live and on-demand.

NBC’s Internet coverage almost makes you think that the advent of a truly convergent mix on TV, Internet and personal content is here. But it wasn’t always this way and the genre still leaves a lot to be desired, whether you are using one of Microsoft’s Media Center extenders, or Internet enabled Linux based extenders from 2-Wire and AT&T, HP or other modem-router makers and soon to be joining the fray TV makers like Samsung.

About ten years ago several leading personal computer firms partnered with Microsoft and/or with the big modem-router makers like Linksys, D-Link and 2-Wire to offer a product for around $300 that would enable you to get some of your PC and Internet content on your TV. Some industry wag reported after the first six months of sales of these content extenders that he couldn’t find one retailer selling them or more than a few even early adopters using or buying them. He’s probably right. I interviewed quite a few leading tech columnists and reporters who were given these devices and could only find one in 25 that would admit to using one even though they got it for free.

The biggest problem both technologically and usability-wise was that no one wanted their PC or early Internet content on their TV and vice versa, and that if they did, because of the computer based format of media extenders, the devices hardly worked or were too difficult to set up.

Because company’s like TiVo, VuDu and Apple TV are leading the way in getting consumers comfortable in configuring routers and software in order to allow these device to deliver PC and Internet based content and vice versa, Microsoft, AT&T, Comcast and Cablevision and others are re-launching their media extenders, hopefully this time with a little more usability and reliability.

Since it seems that more and more consumers want digital convergence and are watching video on their PC and PC content on their TV, I have recently taken a look at this next generation of media extender to see if the manufacturers got it right yet.


About the Author:
Richard M. Sherwin - Contributing Writer
Richard Sherwin is a former syndicated technology columnist and TV/Radio analyst, who has also been a marketing executive with IBM, Philips, NBC and a chief advisor to several manufacturers and service providers.


This entry has been viewed 2413 times.

Article Topics

Social Bookmark   less


Comments (3) Most recent displayed first.
Posted by Jude  on  08/20/08  at  04:34 PM

@Steve I had an Xbox 360 and it was too loud and too hot for my theater. 

Now my old Xbox is pretty silent and with XBMC it does the trick, although not HD.  Still waiting for a good choice.  Maybe the new LG Blu-Ray with built in NetFlix streaming but I doubt it’ll catch on.

Posted by Steve  on  08/20/08  at  08:54 AM

Honestly why would anyone purchase a media extender for $300 when you can have an X-Box 360 for the same cost. I understand form factor issues [read: size] but for the added value for no extra cost, its just plain silly not to.

Posted by Richard  on  08/20/08  at  07:29 AM

I deal with client’s home entertainment needs all the time. The simple answer to your question, “Are Media Extenders Finally Catching On?” is no they are not.

Most people are not interested in this technology. They are still trying to deal with the shift to HDTV. Furthermore, normal people are overwhelmed by the myriad choices and DRM issues that come with media extenders. They have better things to do with their lives than waste time and money on this poorly implemented CE nonsense.

If the industry took the approach of making content available to viewers and listeners where they want it and when they want it, delivered in an easy to understand and hookup manner, this would be a booming market. As currently implemented it seems destined for fanatics and enthusiasts only.



Post a Comment

Name:

Email:


View comment guidelines

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please answer the question below:

Type the last letter of the word "cable":





Learn more about products and solutions from tech companies.
Electronic House magazine's 2008 Best Homes of the Year special.
Electronic House reviews the coolest products of the year.
Get all the information you need to network your entire home.

Stay up-to-date with home electronics. Get your print subscription today.
Weekly email offers tips, info and product news.
Subscribe today!
Get the content that's important to you.
More about RSS.
Electronic House is now available in a digital edition. Learn more.
About us Advertise Magazine Newsletters Digital issues EH Publishing Privacy policy Contact us
 Copyright © 2006 EH Publishing. All rights reserved.
EH Network: CE Pro TecHome Builder ChannelPro ProSoundWeb Church Production Electronic House Expo Worship Facilities Expo